Seated or lying leg curl: which builds more hamstring?

In a 12-week study, the hamstrings grew 14.1% on the seated leg curl and 9.3% on the lying one. Why sitting stretches the muscle, and how to use that when you pick your machine.

If both machines are free, take the seated leg curl. In a 12-week study, the hamstrings grew about 1.5 times as much on the seated machine as on the lying one.

The lying curl still built muscle. It just built less.

What did the study test?

Researchers in Japan had 20 adults train one leg on a seated leg curl and the other on a lying one, assigned at random. Nobody had done regular strength training in the year before.

Both legs did exactly the same work: twice a week for 12 weeks, 5 sets of 10 reps at 70% of their one-rep max, two seconds up and two seconds down, through the same knee range.

Only the hip angle differed. Seated, the hip was bent to about 90 degrees. Lying, it was nearly straight, at about 30 degrees.

How much did the hamstrings grow?

On MRI, the hamstrings grew 14.1% in the seated leg and 9.3% in the lying leg.

The result: Training the same knee movement with the hip bent (seated leg curl) grew the hamstrings 14.1% in 12 weeks, against 9.3% with the hip straight (lying leg curl). Maeo and colleagues, 2021.

Strength rose by about the same in both legs. The difference showed up in muscle size.

Why does sitting make the difference?

Three of your four hamstring muscles start at your sit bone, above the hip joint, and run down past the knee. When you sit, your hip bends and pulls those muscles long before you even start curling.

So on the seated machine, they work in a stretched position. On the lying machine, they work shorter.

The study shows this muscle by muscle. The three that cross the hip all grew more in the seated leg:

Muscle Seated Lying
Biceps femoris, long head +14.4% +6.5%
Semitendinosus +23.6% +19.3%
Semimembranosus +8.2% +3.6%
Biceps femoris, short head (doesn’t cross the hip) +10% +9%

The fourth one, the short head of the biceps femoris, starts below the hip. For it, the hip angle changes nothing, and it grew the same on both machines.

The same pattern shows up in the calves, where the muscle that crosses the knee grew far more on standing calf raises than on seated ones.

The stretched-position explanation is the authors’ reading. The study compared the two machines, it didn’t test other possible causes.

How should you train your hamstrings?

Make the seated leg curl your default. If your gym only has the lying leg curl, use it without worry: it grew the hamstrings by 9% in the same 12 weeks.

Hip-hinge exercises like the Romanian deadlift also load the hamstrings with a bent hip, so they pair well with either curl.

These were 20 adults new to strength training, measured on one machine pair, so treat the 1.5 times as a direction rather than an exact number for your own legs.

All posts